VNDLY vs Katana MRP: Stop Paying for Features You Don't Need

VNDLY vs Katana MRP: Stop Paying for Features You Don't Need

Katana is a well-built piece of software, but it's a manufacturing tool wearing an inventory management costume. If you actually make physical products from raw materials, it might be exactly what you need. But if you're a wholesaler, distributor, retailer, or B2B product business, you're paying a serious premium for a factory floor you don't have.

This post unpacks the difference between MRP (Material Requirements Planning) software and inventory management software, and why mixing them up costs product businesses hundreds of dollars a month.

What Is Katana MRP, Exactly?

Katana describes itself as a "cloud inventory platform," but its feature list makes clear where it belongs. Its standout capabilities include:

• Bills of Materials (BOM): Define the recipe for each finished product, which raw materials, in what quantities
• Manufacturing orders: Track production runs from materials to finished goods
• Shop floor control: Assign tasks to production staff, track time per operation
• Manufacturing cost insights: Cost per production order, planned vs. actual comparison

These are powerful features if you're running a small manufacturing operation. But if your business model is buy → stock → sell, you're paying for a production module that does nothing for you.

The "Manufacturing Tax", What Non-Manufacturers Pay

Every dollar you spend on Katana's manufacturing features is wasted if you don't manufacture.

Katana's paid plans start at $299/month. For that price, you're bundling:

• BOM management you won't use
• Manufacturing orders you won't create
• Shop floor controls your team will never touch
• Production cost tracking that's irrelevant to your margins

Reviewers on software comparison sites have called it out directly. One user noted: "If your business sells a lot of small-ticket orders, you get punished with pricing far beyond the value you actually consume." Another reported migrating to a competitor that was "roughly ¼ of the cost" after finding Katana's pricing unsustainable for their workflow.

Wholesalers, distributors, and retailers need something different: smart inventory management, clean order workflows, accurate margin tracking, and demand forecasting that predicts what to buy next. That's what VNDLY is built for.

Feature-by-Feature Comparison

The Pricing Reality

The numbers are straightforward.

That's a $250/month difference at entry level, or $3,000/year, for a plan that pushes features you don't need. Scale that up to Katana's higher tiers and you're looking at potentially $5,000+ annually in unnecessary spend.

What VNDLY Does That Katana Doesn't

VNDLY specifically fits non-manufacturing businesses better in a few areas:

Who Should Use Katana?

To be fair, Katana is a solid product for its target market. If you're a small manufacturer, a cosmetics brand that mixes its own formulas, a furniture maker assembling from timber and hardware, a food producer running batch production, Katana's BOM and manufacturing order features are valuable.

Who Should Use VNDLY?

VNDLY is purpose-built for the other side of the product business world:

• Wholesalers managing hundreds of SKUs across multiple customers and locations
• Distributors who need clean purchase-to-sale workflows with real margin tracking
• Retailers (online and physical) who need Shopify or WooCommerce connected to a central inventory brain
• B2B product companies with sales reps, agents, and commission structures
• Importers who need landed cost tracking to understand true product costs

These businesses don't need a BOM. They need smart stock management, accurate forecasting, and clean order workflows at a price that doesn't punish them for not having a factory.

From the Founder

By Henrik Åberg, founder of VNDLY

When I ran my product company, I spent years managing inventory as a product business, buying from suppliers, managing stock across multiple channels, tracking what was actually selling versus what was sitting. I wasn't manufacturing anything. I was buying, stocking, and selling.

Every tool I looked at either assumed I had a factory (Katana, Fishbowl) or was a glorified spreadsheet (most "simple inventory" apps). The gap was obvious: there's a massive category of businesses, wholesalers, importers, B2B distributors, that needed something different.

That's why VNDLY exists. The AI piece matters more than people realize. When you're managing hundreds of SKUs, you don't have time to manually review each product's sales trend and calculate reorder points by hand. You need software that tells you what to buy, when, and how much automatically. Katana doesn't do that. We built it from day one.

The $49 starting price isn't a loss leader. It's what inventory management software should cost when you're not paying for a factory control system baked in.

Making the Switch from Katana to VNDLY

If you're currently using Katana but not using its manufacturing features, switching is straightforward:

1. Export your product catalog from Katana (CSV)
2. Import into VNDLY, our onboarding handles bulk product uploads
3. Connect your sales channels (Shopify, WooCommerce), syncs in minutes
4. Set reorder points and stock projections for your key SKUs
5. Enable AI forecasting with your own API key (BYOK, you control costs)

Most teams are up and running within a day. You'll notice quickly what you were missing: stock projections that tell you what's coming, landed cost tracking that gives you real margin numbers, and demand planning that learns from your actual sales data.

Looking for more comparisons? See how VNDLY stacks up against Cin7 and other inventory platforms.